\begin{table}[htbp]\centering
\def\sym#1{\ifmmode^{#1}\else\(^{#1}\)\fi}
\caption{The effect of negative group appeals on statement evaluation}
\begin{tabular}{l*{4}{c}}
\hline\hline
                &\multicolumn{1}{c}{Accounting for group membership}&\multicolumn{1}{c}{Group membership only}&\multicolumn{1}{c}{Accounting for group identification}&\multicolumn{1}{c}{Group identification only}\\
\hline
Group appeal    &     0.30\sym{**} &    -0.66\sym{***}&     0.33\sym{**} &    -0.63\sym{***}\\
                &   (0.10)         &   (0.06)         &   (0.10)         &   (0.05)         \\
Group-policy appeal&     0.64\sym{***}&    0.088         &     0.64\sym{***}&    0.100\sym{*}  \\
                &   (0.09)         &   (0.05)         &   (0.09)         &   (0.05)         \\
Group affect    &    -0.23\sym{***}&                  &    -0.22\sym{***}&                  \\
                &   (0.02)         &                  &   (0.02)         &                  \\
Group appeal $\times$ Group affect&    -0.22\sym{***}&                  &    -0.22\sym{***}&                  \\
                &   (0.02)         &                  &   (0.02)         &                  \\
Group-policy appeal $\times$ Group affect&    -0.13\sym{***}&                  &    -0.12\sym{***}&                  \\
                &   (0.02)         &                  &   (0.02)         &                  \\
Group member    &    -0.98\sym{***}&    -1.01\sym{***}&                  &                  \\
                &   (0.12)         &   (0.13)         &                  &                  \\
Group appeal $\times$ Group member&     0.81\sym{***}&     0.34\sym{*}  &                  &                  \\
                &   (0.15)         &   (0.16)         &                  &                  \\
Group-policy appeal $\times$ Group member&    0.073         &    -0.12         &                  &                  \\
                &   (0.16)         &   (0.16)         &                  &                  \\
Group identification&                  &                  &    -1.18\sym{***}&    -1.32\sym{***}\\
                &                  &                  &   (0.15)         &   (0.15)         \\
Group appeal $\times$ Group identification&                  &                  &     0.72\sym{***}&     0.14         \\
                &                  &                  &   (0.19)         &   (0.20)         \\
Group-policy appeal $\times$ Group identification&                  &                  &   -0.093         &    -0.34         \\
                &                  &                  &   (0.20)         &   (0.20)         \\
\_cons          &     7.39\sym{***}&     5.94\sym{***}&     7.34\sym{***}&     5.98\sym{***}\\
                &   (0.12)         &   (0.09)         &   (0.11)         &   (0.08)         \\
\hline
Observations    &    22050         &    22050         &    22050         &    22050         \\
FEs respondents &      Yes         &      Yes         &      Yes         &      Yes         \\
FEs groups      &      Yes         &      Yes         &      Yes         &      Yes         \\
Respondents     &     3150         &     3150         &     3150         &     3150         \\
R\textsuperscript{2}&     0.17         &     0.11         &     0.17         &     0.12         \\
\hline\hline
\multicolumn{5}{l}{\footnotesize Note: Clustered standard errors (by respondents) in parentheses.}\\
\multicolumn{5}{l}{\footnotesize \sym{*} \(p<0.5\), \sym{**} \(p<0.01\), \sym{***} \(p<0.001\)}\\
\end{tabular}
\end{table}
